| Rachael Beeer | Central Community | |||
| Gracie Kimmle | Mascoutah | Mount Mercy University | ||
| Kaylee Bierman | Centralia | |||
| Kassie Weideman | Pana | |||
| Molly Detmer | Central Community | |||
| Chloe Whited | Jerseyville | |||
| Brooklynn Belford | Massac Country | |||
| Academic All-American Team | ||||
| 2022-2023 | ||||
| Academic All-American Team | ||||
| 2021-2022 | ||||
| Academic All-American Team | ||||
| 2020-2021 | ||||
| Academic All-American Team | ||||
| 2019-2020 | ||||
| Morgan Scruggs | Mt. Vernon | Indiana University Kokomo | ||
| Jenny Buchanan | Harrisburg | |||
| Ashley Fritsche | Saxony Lutheran | |||
| Taylor Hobbbs | Murphysboro | |||
| 2018-2019 | ||||
| Madilyn Glover | Wesclin | |||
| Jenny Buchanan | Harrisburg | |||
| Ashley Fritsche | Saxony Lutheran | |||
| Alisse Koishor | Highland | Missouri Baptist University | ||
| 2017-2018 | ||||
| Academic All-American Team | ||||
| Abigail Henken | Mt. Vernon | |||
| Hannah Bartok | Harrisburg | Lindenwood Belleville University | ||
| Kara Gunter | Belleville East | |||
| Addison Schindler | Perryville | Lindenwood St. Charles University | ||
| Marissa Woolfolk | Carlinville | Blackburn College | ||
| Brooklynn Hamman | Noth Posey | Missouri Baptist University | ||
| Emily Krebs | Mater Dei | Lindenwood St. Charles University | ||
| Alisse Koishor | Highland | |||
| 2016-2017 | ||||
| Academic All-American Team | ||||
| Abigail Ingenrieth | Centralia | |||
| Adrianna Oxley | Heritage Hills | |||
| Brooke Moll | Perryville | Southeast Missouri State | ||
| Brooklynn Hamman | North Posey | |||
| Shelby Brandmeyer | Wesclin | Greenville College | ||
| Katie Williams | Argos | |||
| Kylie Bilek | Perryville | |||
| Hannah Bartok | Harrisburg | |||
| Emily Krebs | Mater Dei | |||
| 2015-2016 | ||||
| Academic All-American Team | ||||
| Shelby Brandmeyer | Wesclin | |||
| Rachel Hanold | Gibson Southern | Oakland City University | ||
| Mariah Dunavan | Christ Our Rock | |||
| Makenzie Burgess | Charleston | |||
| Kylee Ledbetter | Carlyle | Southern Illinois University | ||
| Brookle Moll | Perryville | |||
| 2014-2015 | ||||
| Academic All-American Team | ||||
| Lauren Krebs | Mater Dei | Missouri Baptist University | ||
| Megan Zurliene | Mater Dei | University of Illinois | ||
|
2013-2014 |
|
|||
|
Lauren Krebs |
Mater Dei |
Missouri Baptist University |
||
|
2012-2013 |
|
|
||
|
Alison Koerkenmeier |
Wesclin |
Hartford University |
||
|
Chelsey Henrichs |
Breese Central |
Mckendree University |
||
|
2011-2012 |
|
|
||
|
Kelsey Miller |
Boonville |
Kentucky Wesleyan |
||
|
Ann Childerson |
Altamont |
Greenville College |
||
|
Emily Frohn |
Breese Central |
Southern Illinois University |
||
|
Academic All-American Team |
|
|
||
|
2010-2011 |
|
|
||
|
Katelyn Novak |
East Richland |
Missouri S & T |
||
|
Mackenzie Hartman |
Pendleton Heights |
Indiana University |
||
|
Kelly Koester |
Effingham |
University of Illinois |
||
|
Academic All-American Team |
|
|
||
|
2009-2010 |
|
|
||
|
Dana Hagen |
Breese Central |
Southern Illinois University |
||
|
Tiffany Hilmes |
Breese Central |
Eastern Illinois University |
||
|
Ansley Murphy |
Mt. Vernon |
Southern Illinois University |
||
|
Academic All-American Team |
|
|